Agenda and minutes

Licensing Appeals Sub-Committee - Monday, 14 September 2020 10.30 a.m.

Venue: Virtual meeting - Online. View directions

Contact: Victoria Wallace  03450 450 500 Email:


No. Item


Introductions / Procedure pdf icon PDF 205 KB

The Chairman of the Sub-Committee will welcome those present and introduce him/herself; the remaining members of the Sub-Committee and the officers will then introduce themselves.


A copy of the Sub-Committee appeals procedure is attached.


The Chair introduced officers and panel members and welcomed the licensee to the hearing.  


Declarations of Interest


There were no declarations of interest.


Referral to the Licensing Appeals Sub-Committee to consider the fit and proper status to continue as a Private Hire Driver licence


The Sub-Committee heard representations from the licensee and licensing officer, based on the written report. The Sub-Committee also considered written representations from the licensee’s legal representative.


The Sub-Committee revoked the Private Hire Driver Licence.




In making its decision the sub-committee considered the following:


      Statutory provisions: S51,61 & 77 Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions Act) 1976

      Statutory taxi and private hire vehicle standards issued by the Department of Transport in July 2020.

      South Cambridgeshire District Council Private Hire and Taxi Policy

      Report of the Licensing Officer

      Advice from the Council’s legal adviser

      Representations from the Licensing Officer

      Written representations submitted by the licensee’s legal representative

      Evidence as referred to above.



The sub-committee made its decision for the following reasons:

      The sub-committee determined that the licensee’s actions breached the conditions of his licence at 2b Conduct of Driver. The licensee admitted he had not behaved in an orderly manner.

      In accordance with the licensing authority’s policy in place at the time of the incident, at 12.8 the policy stated an application would normally be refused where the applicant has a conviction for an offence of obstruction.

      Statutory guidance issued in July 2020 from the Department of Transport states that decisions need to be made on the balance of probability and emphasises that if the sub-committee is only ’50:50’ as to whether the licensee is fit and proper the driver should not hold a licence.

      The sub-committee was concerned by the licensee’s actions which obstructed a normal police activity and demonstrated a disregard for the rule of law.

      The sub-committee was concerned by the licensee’s attitude towards a police enforcement activity.